Blog Layout

Apollo's Vap-X 3 Phase and Vap-X Gas Blend Can Help Bring Shut-In Production Back Online

Sebastian Guenther • April 1, 2022

Challenge

Find a solution for hydrogen sulfide (H2S) treatment for H2S oil/gas in the Permian Basin for shut-in legacy wells. 

Solution

Apply Apollo's Vap-X™ suite of chemistries to improve, manage, and mitigate H2S and CO2 in oil/gas/water phases or each individually. It will allow producer to manage gas in the midstream sales line.

Results

  • Reduce H2S and CO2 levels to allow for gas sales.
  • Improve overall safety and integrity of company assets.
  • Demonstrated the effectiveness of Apollo's Vap-X™ suite of chemistry at mitigating H2S and CO2 with minimal side effects.

Apollo's Vap-X™ 3 phase and Vap-X™ gas blend can help bring shut-in production back online.

Multiple Treatment Options Utilizing Both Chemistries

Reduce Hydrogen Sulfide in sour crude oil and gas.

Hydrogen Sulfide is naturally produced from the Permian Basin Formation. The levels can range from a few ppm up to 250,000 ppm hydrogen sulfide and must be reduced to below pipeline specifications. In addition to reducing product value, hydrogen sulfide exposes producers to environmental and safety risk. It also can increase the chance of corrosion.


Producer in West Texas currently deals with high levels of H2S. In some particular batteries levels are so high that it has forced producers to leave wells shut-in. Apollo suggested treating the Hydrogen Sulfide using their Vap-X 3 Phase product which will reduce the H2S in gas phase (as well as oil and water phase)thus allowing for a lower gas spec. This reduced level can then be sold to midstream for gas processing. Apollo, then utilizes its √ap-X™ Oil Blend product to treat the oil stream after separation to < 10 ppm of H2S,therefore meeting for pipeline specifications and midstream sales requirements. 

3 Foot Static Mixer Installed

The initial pilot began on January 29, 2022. The goal of the pilot was to return to the well back to continuous production with the oil level of H2S below 10ppm and the gas level of H2S with 50% reduction. The picture above shows the well coming into the facility as a commingled stream. Apollo suggested a 3 foot static mixer to help with blending the chemistry into all three phases which in turn would lower the dosage rate was installed that allowed Apollo to introduce Vap-X 3 phase blend into the stream. Apollo also asked for the installation of three different testing ports. These ports allow Apollo to monitor the streams for H2S ppm reduction, water ph, along with fluid rates. Apollo's Vap-X 3 phase reduces H2S and CO2 in all three streams. The initial startup of the well came with numerous challenges since the well has been shut-in for an extended period of time. We experienced very sporadic flows as well as very high H2S and CO2 raw numbers upon startup. The initial numbers were 250,000 ppm of H2S as well as 250,000 ppm of CO2.


The Vap-X 3 phase chemistry is designed to greatly reduce both H2S and CO2 in all three streams. This particular well is very unique in two different ways. First, the oil/water phase H2S and CO2 is typically lower than gas phase. This was not the case for the well. This required higher dosing. Second, the CO2 concentration in the oil and gas was much higher than anticipated requiring a higher dosage rate (Vap-X is not selective for H2S only but will also mitigate CO2). We brought the well online on 01/29/2022. Production rates and H2S concentrations fluctuated a lot during the first two weeks of testing. Production shut-ins occurred a couple of times during the test. Initial dosage rates of Vap-X 3-Phase were in the 70-75 gallons per hour. Reductions in H2S and CO2 occurred almost immediately and ranged between 40%-69% over the first 7 days. The tables below show results sampling during the test. The raw and the treated H2S numbers represent the concentrations in the gas phase. Apollo also measured the water pH in the mixer and at the free water knockout to monitor for conditions that would allow for potential solids to form.

Date Time Raw H2S PPM Treated H2S PPM Mixer PH Knock PH
01/29/22 6:34 PM 150,000 78,000 NA NA
01/30/22 12:47 PM 150,00 78,000 9.5 8.5
01/30/22 1:21 PM SHUT-IN

As the well came back online on 1/31/2022 we once again noticed high fluctuations in the raw ppm of H2S. However, one of the unique characteristics of the Vap-X™ suite of chemistries is that they are able to deal with burps(high fluctuations) of H2S unlike anything on the market. Which makes it ideal for wellhead application especially when dealing with elevated H2S levels that tend to hit pockets of high H2S occasionally (ie..100k ppm jumping to150k ppm)

Date Time Raw H2S PPM Treated H2S PPM Mixer PH Knock PH
01/31/22 6:04 PM 110,000 52,000 9 6.2
02/01/22 9:05 AM 170,000 65,000 9 6.79
02/01/22 2:10 PM 130,000 40,000 8.77 6.78
02/01/22 8:03 PM 120,000 60,000 NA 7
02/02/22 9:53 AM 110,000 55,000 NA 7.89
02/02/22 12:29 PM SHUT-IN

We received word from midstream company that we had to shut-in due to constraints at their plant due to another customer. Then due to weather (cold front) we had to keep the well shut-in because the pumps had to be defrosted. Once that got situated we went back to pumping chemistry on 2/3/2022 at 2:30 pm. We continued to get very good results however Apollo felt dosage could be improved from the 70-75 gallons/hour.

Date Time Raw H2S PPM Treated H2S PPM Mixer PH Knock PH
02/03/22 4:24 PM 118,000 55,000 NA 7.25
02/03/22 6:11 PM 120,000 53,000 NA 7.7
02/04/22 2:42 PM 115,000 55,000 NA 7.5

Apollo working along with the producer suggested utilizing an additional chemistry from the Vap-X™ suite. The Vap-X™ gas blend chemistry which would be introduced via the inlet to the scrubber. Apollo would also introduce a water wash into line to insure flow and allow any contaminants (salt mainly) the ability to be absorbed back into the water phase. This is an application that Apollo has applied for a patent, due to the application and chemistry. Apollo utilized both Vap-X™ 3 phase and Vap-X™ gas only. Apollo continued to inject Vap-X™3 phase chemistry via the static mixer point. While simultaneously polishing the gas via the injection points before the scrubber as seen below. 


The amount of water needed for the water wash is a formula based on the expected MMCF, as well as the H2S and CO2 ppm associated with the gas stream. Since this stream has an estimated flow of around 1.2 MMCF per day as well as 15% of both H2S and CO2 respectively, the water utilized via this application requires a large dosage pump similar to the chemistry. The picture below shows the pump configuration at the scrubber injection for the gas only stream as well as the chemical pump for the three phase injection.

Patent Pending Water Wash Application

Dosage Pumps for Vap-X™ 3 Phase, Vap-X™ Gas Blend, Water Wash

As we started up the initial injection point at the inlet of the scrubber the well continued to spike up and down. During the night of Feb 5th and morning of Feb 6th the raw ppm of H2S spiked to over 200,000 ppm. However with the injection of the Vap-X™ suite of chemistries (VapX™ 3 phase and Vap-X™ gas blend) at the two different spots we noticed it was able to handle the spikes easier. We were; however, continuing to use 70 gal/hour between the two injection points.

Date Time Raw H2S PPM Treated H2S PPM Mixer PH Knock PH
02/05/22 12:34 PM 162,000 80,000 NA 7
02/06/22 10:41 AM 108,000 57,000 NA 7.67
02/06/22 4:31 PM 107,000 55,000 NA 7.68
02/07/22 7:22 AM 110,000 57,000 NA 7.09

From 2/8 to 2/10 the well was shut-in. After discussions of inconsistencies between producer and Apollo, producer started to realize the inconsistencies of the well flow was due to the ESP (Electrical submersible pump) having outdated software. The decision was made that we needed to get some consistent raw H2S numbers before we started to introduce chemical back into the system. Apollo also after analyzing our data from the previous two weeks wanted to introduce the Vap-X gas blend only thru the injection points at the inlet of the scrubber (no longer use Vap-X™ 3 phase). The morning of 2/11 is when the well would come back online and the raw H2S data would be collected.

Date Time Raw H2S PPM Treated H2S PPM Mixer PH Knock PH
02/11/22 7:00 AM 121,000 NA NA NA
02/11/22 8:00 AM 121,000 NA NA NA
02/11/22 9:00 AM 121,000 NA NA NA
02/11/22 10:00 AM 119,000 NA NA NA
02/11/22 11:00 AM 116,000 NA NA NA

As the well stabilized and it seemed to be running around 120,000 ppm of H2S consistently Apollo was allowed to reintroduce the chemistry as Vap-X™ gas blend only via the injections on the inlet of the scrubber. Apollo instantly noticed a reduction of chemistry from the 70 gal/hour down to 55 gal/hour at initial startup. This was over a 20% reduction compared to the other two previous applications. However on 2/12 Apollo was able to reduce the chemistry usage another 10 gallons/hour down to 45 gal/hour. By switching to a gas only application for the well Apollo was able to reduce the chemistry over 40% from the initial 75 gal/hour down to 45 gal/hour. Apollo was able to maintain this dosage for all of 2/12 and into the morning of 2/13. However the well continued to deal with sporadic flow due to the software being outdated. It was decided to shut-in the well to change a back pressure valve. 

Date Time Raw H2S PPM Treated H2S PPM Mixer PH Knock PH
02/11/22 1:32 PM 120,000 70,000 NA NA
02/11/22 3:07 PM 120,000 62,000 NA NA
02/12/22 10:07 AM 128,000 64,000 NA NA
02/12/22 3:11 PM 120,000 52,000 NA NA
02/13/22 8:09 AM SHUT-IN

As Apollo was monitoring the well it also noticed the gas stream CO2(which fluctuated between 80,000 to 120,000ppm) was consistently around 2% after treatment. Producer informed Apollo that the midstream company views H2S and CO2 as the same meaning they take the combined ppm for their threshold limits. This is a HUGE benefit to the Vap-X™ suite of chemistries because we are getting the H2S reduction that has been well documented as well as a significant reduction in CO2 as well. As Apollo continued to run the chemistry on 2/16 they noticed the reduction was basically the same utilizing 45 gal/hour or 40 gal/hour. After much trial in the field Apollo has came to the conclusion for this particular well the best application is utilizing the inlet injection at the scrubber. Apollo during the field trial also was able to reduce the dosage from 75 gal/hour down to 40 gal/hour saving the producer substantial money.

Date Time Raw H2S PPM Treated H2S PPM Mixer PH Knock PH
02/16/22 9:53 AM 121,000 55,000 NA NA
02/16/22 1:56 PM 118,000 55,000 NA NA
02/16/22 5:01 PM SHUT-IN

After the successful test Apollo met with the producer on 2/17. During that meeting it was decided to setup the Whiskey River 19.5 battery for permanent injection. Apollo asked producer to add static mixers into the other two headers coming into the battery. They also suggested to the producer that some type of automation would be needed so that if the well shut-off the chemical would do the same. Producer agreed to put a valve to cut off air supply to the dosage pumps. Apollo also stated that depending on the treatment of the other wells (meaning how much Vap-X™ 3 phase could be utilized before the scrubber) would determine if an additional scrubber would need to be added to deal with the liquid of the chemical as well as the water from the water wash. Apollo is hoping that the other 4 wells that come into the battery will utilize some of the Vap-X™ 3 phase chemistry which would lower the Vap-X™ gas only chemistry used. However, due to the Vap-X™ suite of chemistry the producer has many options for optimal reduction with minimal chemistry.


As Apollo continued to treat the well on 2/18-2/19 utilizing the injection points at the inlet of the gas scrubber the reduction in H2S and CO2 was continuing to stabilize. Apollo was able to continue to get the reduction at the new dosage rate of 40 gal/hour. In the early morning hours of 2/20 the well shut-in. Since we did not have any automation setup to turn the pumps off, the chemical as well as the water wash continued to run even though there was no gas present. Due to this there was a buildup of solids (salt) at the scrubber dump. Samples were taken and dissolved back in water to verify that salt was the issue. When the proper shut off valves are installed for the chemical pumps this issue will not happen.

Date Time Raw H2S PPM Treated H2S PPM Mixer PH Knock PH
02/17/22 11:49 AM 112,000 50,000 NA NA
02/18/22 3:58 PM 122,000 55,000 NA NA
02/19/22 10:07 AM 118,000 60,000 NA NA
02/19/22 2:53 PM 120,000 62,000 NA NA

The testing for the well was very successful. If we look at an average of 150,000 ppm of both H2S and CO2 and the ability to get these elements down to 50,000 ppm at the sale lines is a monumental leap in chemistry ability. If we are able to quantify these results with 40 gal/hour, then we would be able to deal with H2S < $1.75 Lbs/S and CO2 < $1.75 Lbs/C. Apollo feels as other wells come online in this battery we will see a continued drop in price for Lbs for both elements. By utilizing the Vap-X suite of chemistry Apollo feels we will be able to help the producer tap into roughly 15,000 bbl/day of shut-in production with minimal Cap-X outlay. This particular well proved 800 of such barrels.

By Sebastian Guenther April 1, 2022
The MolChem3™ process is a proprietary process which utilizes a sulfur recovery process. In this process, we sweeten the gas stream and produce elemental sulfur. Through our reactor-absorber tower, the process reacts H2S in the presence of SO2 which in turn produces free sulfur. The sweet residue will then be effectively dehydrated. The Carbon Dioxide stream in the gas phase does not impact the reaction mechanism. Therefore we are not having chemical uptake associated with the CO2 stream, which makes the process more efficient. The MolChem3™ process is ideal for producers that have consistent sulfur issues that require more capacity than a typical bubble tower, but not nearly enough to support an amine system. MolChem3™ takes advantage of lower operating and energy cost compared. Also allows great flexibility in variable volume, as well as H2S levels, while not affecting economics. Fast application build/delivery, while maintaining the economics of a regenerative chemistry with best in industry downtime. MolChem3™ has a proprietary automation system which controls contact time based on H2S levels, gas flow, and oxidation potential. Greatly reduce CO2 and VOC emissions to help change the climate footprint.
By Sebastian Guenther April 1, 2022
lab procedure
By Sebastian Guenther April 1, 2022
lab procedure
By Sebastian Guenther April 1, 2022
Vap-X™ Oil Blend has been formulated to greatly reduce H2S and CO2 in an oil stream with excess water.. It can reduce the oil H2S and CO2 by 50-70%. When acid gas is present the water phase tends to be at acidic levels. VapX™ Oil Blend is engineered to neutralize the acids thereby converting the H2S out of the sulfide phase. In many battery applications water plays a main role in causing scale especially when a high pH chemical is introduced to mitigate the H2S. Vap-X Oil Blend proprietary blend has a chemical that inhibits the fallout of precipitants even at an elevated pH. It also has a corrosion inhibitor built into the chemistry as well. A static mixer is used to apply the chemistry and allow the chemistry to migrate thru the oil column. . Vap-X™ Oil Blend is best utilized in high H2S concentrations with with water being present. The dosing rate is based on volume of liquid flow rate therefore it is ideal to be used via a automative pump. Vap-X™ 3 OIl Blend also has a proprietary chemical additive that acts as a corrosion inhibitor.
By Sebastian Guenther April 1, 2022
Vap-X™ 3 Phase has been formulated to greatly reduce H2S and CO2 in an oil, water, and gas system. It effectively reduces all three streams by 50-70% of its H2S and CO2. The product adjust the pH of the water from the acidic phase to a neutral pH once the reaction is complete. Vap-X™ 3 Phase is engineered with a higher RVP allowing the treatment of the gas phase via gas partitioning. The chemical is applied utilizing a static mixer via a commingled stream (oil, gas, and water) allowing for turbulent mixing between the three phases. A critical aspect of the treatment is the mixing energy to make sure all the molecules have contact with the solution. With very minimal capital expenditure this product will show how it can impact a field. Bring shut-in production back online with ability to treat previously thought to be uneconomical wells to produce. Vap-X™ 3 Phase is best utilized in high H2S concentrations with consistent liquid flow. The dosing rate is based on volume of liquid flow rate and water volume where pH is controlled to help mitigate fallout from occurring. Vap-X™ 3 Phase also has a proprietary chemical additive that acts as a corrosion inhibitor.
By Sebastian Guenther April 1, 2022
Apcotane H20TM has been formulated to mitigate H2S and CO2 with minimal dosage. The product changes the pH of the water from acidic to neutral. This is when H2S is no longer in the sulfide phase. The product also is built to be able to help maintain a neutral pH therefore not allowing for fallout of precipitants. Apcotane H2OTM is stream dependent not ppm-dependent, so dosage is based on the stream of the water. The critical aspect of the treatment is the mixing energy to make sure all the molecules have contact with the solution. The product targets all organic and inorganic sulfides such as mercaptans and iron sulfide. Apcotane H2OTM has many different applications in the oil and gas industry. Chemistry was built to deal with produced and fracking water.
By Sebastian Guenther April 1, 2022
One of the first concerns from Taprock about our products is that they have an elevated pH. As we discussed, Apollo has taken the next step with its Vap-XTM Oil Blend product formulating to be oil-soluble. This breakthrough product allows the H2S to be mitigated, still utilizing the organic molecule to form a covalent bond with bisulfate in the crude stream. Additional patented chemistry is added to insure no fallout in either the oil or water phase. Furthermore, Vap-X Oil Blend has a low specific gravity, allowing it to blend better with the incoming oil streams. Lastly, a pH around 7 in the crude stream, actually is at the ideal level to maximizes Vap-XTM Oil Blend treating goals: 1. Lower chemical usage 2. NO precipitation 3. Meet H2S pipeline specs. During our site visit a couple of weeks ago, we received a sample from well #114 at the Gipple CTB. The raw H2S level was 12,000 ppm. Based on 3rd party testing by SPL, we were able to achieve under 10 ppm. However we feel with treating the comingled stream with Vap-X 3 Phase Blend directly will improve H2S crude specs for the entire CTB. We also recommend a couple of upgrades to improve treating at the Gipple CTB. With upcoming construction planned, we recommend the addition of two static mixers, one right after separation with a primary injection point and the second one before the VRU with a secondary injection point. Finally, running the heater treater at around 120°F should improve treating speed and efficiency. Both improvements should enhance treating all three phases. 
By Sebastian Guenther April 1, 2022
Apollo started treating for Parsley on 11/20/2020. At first Apollo started on Whiskey River 19.5 and Whiskey River 5.8. Both of these batteries are in the upper limits of H2S for Parsley. WR 19.5 runs between 80,000-120,000 ppm of H2S and the WR 5.8 runs between 40,000-50,000 ppm of H2S. Apollo treated these wells successfully for 6 months with its patented Apcotane™ product. As Parsley was transitioning into Pioneer Apollo received 14 additional batteries 1. Pecan State B-CH 2. Pecan State C-FH 3. Redbud State KH 4. Redbud State MH 5. Trees Ranch 35-38H 6. Trees State 14-15H 7. Trees State 23-26H 8. Trees State 24-25H 9. Trees State 29-28H 10. Trees State 50-47H 11. Trees State 52-53H 12. UTL Section 30 CTB H 13. UTL Section 44H TB 14. Whiskey River 59H Apollo brought these batteries online at the end of May 2021. Apollo has successfully been able to treat and meet spec over this time frame. Treating these batteries is a unique application in that there is no sales tank. Meaning treatment is applied and then recontaminated with H2S laden oil. For example, the UTL 44 has an oil load line and the lact line a few feet apart but the same height as the tanks. This created a situation in which the oil would have to be overtreated at the circulating pump due to Apcotane™ high specific of gravity. If chemistry was applied on load line, chemistry would not get proper mixing and would fall to bottom of gun barrel tank and into the water cut. Due to this, Apollo did see some issues with the water phase becoming an elevated PH and having solids fall out. Apollo along with Jonathon Poe of Parsley/Pioneer made some suggestions of adding a sales tank. Due to timing they decided not to go with this application. Apollo and Pioneer agreed to add static mixers which would help the mixing capabilities and greatly reduce/eliminate unspent Apcotane™ going in the water column. Static Mixers (for WR 19.5, WR 5.8, UTL 30, UTL 44 and WR 59H) were spec’d and ordered for the aforementioned batteries. With the timing of the purchase by Continental these mixers have not been deployed in the field. Apollo also has an additional oilsoluble chemistry (Vap-X™ Oil Blend) that it has deployed with the Trees 24-25 and Trees 23-26 for over a month since the Continental purchase. The chemistry is working very well with zero issues. We feel with the use of the Vap-X™ Oil Blend chemistry along with the static mixers we would be able to greatly reduce dosage rates as well as adverse problems associated with the application. The UTL 30 and UTL 44 oil production has fallen off drastically since Apollo treatment ceased. Based on the numbers Apollo feels it could bring roughly an additional 3500 bbl. online per day at UTL 44 now utilizing Vap-X™ Oil blend as well as an additional 1500 bbl. at the UTL 30. This increase of 5,000 bbl. a day could be realized immediately. Also, the specs of the oil when Apollo was treating was 100 ppm that has since been adjusted to 1000 ppm which would be a cost benefit to Continental. Apollo is a research and development company that is always striving for continued improvement in our chemistry. Apollo has a state-of-the-art private lab that allows our research scientist to develop and test chemical advancements. Apollo does not offer any off the shelf products that are relabeled. Apollo currently has nine domestic patents, three international patents along with fifty international patents pending. The company also has eleven more patents either in the provisional or pending stage. Apollo sources and blends all its patented and proprietary chemistry in house. Apollo’s chemistry is ground-breaking in the scavenging world in that they have between 20:1 and 40:1 molar ratio when dealing with H2S or CO2. Most other scavengers are 2:1 or best-case scenario 3:1 that is why Apollo’s suite of chemistry utilizes low dosage rates which in turn have the best pricing per bbl. treated. This also will be demonstrated on the dosage comparison sheet. This is an update on the current applications as well as the future applications that Apollo/Pioneer discussed.
By Sebastian Guenther April 1, 2022
Produced water and Hydrocarbons containing soluble and vapor phase H2S (Hydrogen Sulfide)
More Posts
Share by: